Cooks/Landry/Collins question

[lukkyseven]

Trying to go into rebuild mode during a super pot year. So therefore I'm trying to get a little bit more value for my guys. I'm getting offers all over the place such as 2019 1st/2nd/3rd for Cooks or Landry. I'm also seeing things such as Michel or Penny 1 for 1. I don't think the higher round rookies are equal on a one to one trade, but I can appreciate them as being worth more than a 1st.

Any suggestions on value here?

[lukkynumber13]

I’m a little confused as to what you’re asking. Can you break up your post into individual specific questions?

[lukkyseven]

Guess that's what I get for trying to do that from my phone.

I'm in a 2 copy IDP league. Basically I'm trying to figure out the value of Cooks, Landry and Collins in value of 2019 picks.

Since we already drafted for this year, some people are offering the 2018 rookies. Basic value of the guys I have would be helpful.

[lukkynumber13]

Cooks and Landry should both be worth no less than the 1.02 IMO. For me, that means Guice.

Is it Landon Collins or Alex? Either way, he’s worth an early 2nd or MAYBE late First

[lukkyseven]

Most recent offer:

Landry/Hitchens

for

Ballage/Michel/Jatavis Brown

Brown has no value to me and I would have to work on that aspect of the trade. Is Landry for Michel/Ballage fair?

I think what my trading partner is trying to say with this offer is that it's not a fair trade and he's trying to recoup value by getting Hitchens. I think that's just too steep personally.

[Ruggenater]

I still wouldn't do that even if Jatavis and Hitchens were on the opposite sides of that deal. Landry is a fine piece to have in a rebuild since he's still pretty young, but if you're intent on delaying production, maybe try reaching out to the Guice and Chubb owners to see what they'd throw on top for Cooks or Landry.

[lukkynumber13]

I still wouldn't do that even if Jatavis and Hitchens were on the opposite sides of that deal. Landry is a fine piece to have in a rebuild since he's still pretty young, but if you're intent on delaying production, maybe try reaching out to the Guice and Chubb owners to see what they'd throw on top for Cooks or Landry.

I agree with this completely

[lukkyseven]

I'll heed that advice. Before I do, let me throw one last scenario out there.

Landry + Hitchens (or similar ranked LB)

for

DJ Moore 1st/2nd

These are different owners thus the different offer.

[lukkynumber13]

I'll heed that advice. Before I do, let me throw one last scenario out there.

Landry + Hitchens (or similar ranked LB)

for

DJ Moore 1st/2nd

These are different owners thus the different offer.

If that 1st is from really bad team, I’d be very interested