Mock draft competition - discussion thread

[Phish Brigade]

Think I added everything right, this is what I think I got:
#1 St. Louis Rams - QB, Sam Bradford 11 points correct pick
#2 Detroit Lions - DT, Ndamukong Suh 11 points correct pick
#3 Tampa Bay Buccaneers - DT, Gerald McCoy 11 points correct pick
#4 Washington Redskins - OT, Russell Okung 15 points different player, same position, 2 spots off
#5 Kansas City Chiefs - OT, Trent Williams 05 points different position, 2 spots off
#6 Seattle Seahawks - OT, Bryan Bulaga 09 points different player, same position
#7 Cleveland Browns - CB, Eric Berry 09 points different player, correct position
#8 Oakland Raiders - DE, Jason Pierre-Paul 0 points, different position, 6 spots off
#9 Buffalo Bills - QB, Jimmy Clausen 0 points, not even close
#10 Jacksonville Jaguars - DE, Derrick Morgan 0 points, different position, 6 spots off
#11 Denver Broncos - WR, Dez Bryant 0 points, same position, 16 spots off
#12 Miami Dolphins - LB, Rolando McClain 01 point, different position, 4 spots off
#13 San Francisco 49ers - CB, Joe Haden 0 points, different position, 6 spots off
#14 Seattle Seahawks - DE Everson Griffen 0 points, different position, 6 spots off
#15 New York Giants - DT, Dan Williams 0 points, different position, 7 spots off
#16 Tennessee Titans - DE, Brandon Graham 12 points, different player, same position, 3 spots off
#17 San Francisco 49ers - OT, Bruce Campbell 0 points, different position
#18 Pittsburgh Steelers - RB, CJ Spiller 0 points, different position, 9 spots off
#19 Atlanta Falcons - LB, Sergio Kindle 09 points, different player, same position
#20 Houston Texans - S, Earl Thomas 0 points, different position, 6 spots off
#21 Cincinnati Bengals - OG, Mike Iupati 01 point, different position, 4 spots off
#22 New England Patriots - DT, Jared Odrick 0 points, different position, 6 spots off
#23 Green Bay Packers - OT, Anthony Davis 09 points, different player, same position, 12 spots off
#24 Philadelphia Eagles - DE, Carlos Dunlap 0 points, different position, 13 spots off
#25 Baltimore Ravens - CB, Kyle Wilson 01 point, different position, 4 spots off
#26 Arizona Cardinals - LB, Sean Weatherspoon 0 points, different position, 7 spots off
#27 Dallas Cowboys - S, Taylor Mays 0 points, different position, 16 spots off
#28 San Diego Chargers - RB, Ryan Mathews 0 points, same player different spot
#29 New York Jets - DE, Jerry Hughes 05 points, different position, 2 spots off
#30 Minnesota Vikings - DT, Brian Price 0 points, different position
#31 Indianapolis Colts - DT, Tyson Alualu 0 points, different position
#32 New Orleans Saints - DE, Corey Wooten 0 points, different position

Total: 109 points

I'm not sure if that's scored properly or not. I don't know if I have it right either though. I didn't think any pick could score higher than an 11 for being perfect. For example: I gave myself 5 points for Eric Berry at #7 for being 2 picks off.

I also gave myself only 9 points for picking Brandon Graham at #16 ( different player, same exact position ). If that's correct, I don't think Eric Berry at #7 can count for 9 points for you.


Based on those calculations, I scored 126.

Perfect 11 score @ 1,2,3,19,21 = 55 points
9 point score @ 4,6,10,16,20 = 45 points
Plus a 7, a couple of 5's and 3's. Very close at picks 17 and 18, had two OLinemen but wrong positions. If I get 15 points for Okung, my score goes up.

[BradyT]

#1 St. Louis Rams - QB, Sam Bradford 11 points correct pick
#2 Detroit Lions - DT, Ndamukong Suh 11 points correct pick
#3 Tampa Bay Buccaneers - DT, Gerald McCoy 11 points correct pick
#4 Washington Redskins - OT, Russell Okung 15 points different player, same position, 2 spots off 9 points
#5 Kansas City Chiefs - OT, Trent Williams 05 points different position, 2 spots off 7 points - he was selected at #4 and therefore you were 1 spot off
#6 Seattle Seahawks - OT, Bryan Bulaga 09 points different player, same position
#7 Cleveland Browns - CB, Eric Berry 09 points different player, correct position 5 points - Eric Berry is a Safety, not CB, allthough he might play CB from time to time.. but that doesn´t count here
#8 Oakland Raiders - DE, Jason Pierre-Paul 0 points, different position, 6 spots off
#9 Buffalo Bills - QB, Jimmy Clausen 0 points, not even close
#10 Jacksonville Jaguars - DE, Derrick Morgan 0 points, different position, 6 spots off
#11 Denver Broncos - WR, Dez Bryant 0 points, same position, 16 spots off
#12 Miami Dolphins - LB, Rolando McClain 01 point, different position, 4 spots off
#13 San Francisco 49ers - CB, Joe Haden 0 points, different position, 6 spots off
#14 Seattle Seahawks - DE Everson Griffen 0 points, different position, 6 spots off
#15 New York Giants - DT, Dan Williams 0 points, different position, 7 spots off
#16 Tennessee Titans - DE, Brandon Graham 12 points, different player, same position, 3 spots off 9 points, you predicted Graham(DE), they took Morgan(different DE)
#17 San Francisco 49ers - OT, Bruce Campbell 0 points, different position
#18 Pittsburgh Steelers - RB, CJ Spiller 0 points, different position, 9 spots off
#19 Atlanta Falcons - LB, Sergio Kindle 09 points, different player, same position 0 points.. while Kindle might play LB, he´s a DE coming into this draft
#20 Houston Texans - S, Earl Thomas 0 points, different position, 6 spots off
#21 Cincinnati Bengals - OG, Mike Iupati 01 point, different position, 4 spots off
#22 New England Patriots - DT, Jared Odrick 0 points, different position, 6 spots off
#23 Green Bay Packers - OT, Anthony Davis 09 points, different player, same position, 12 spots off
#24 Philadelphia Eagles - DE, Carlos Dunlap 0 points, different position, 13 spots off
#25 Baltimore Ravens - CB, Kyle Wilson 01 point, different position, 4 spots off
#26 Arizona Cardinals - LB, Sean Weatherspoon 0 points, different position, 7 spots off
#27 Dallas Cowboys - S, Taylor Mays 0 points, different position, 16 spots off how do you know about being 16 spots off if he isn´t selected so far..
#28 San Diego Chargers - RB, Ryan Mathews 0 points, same player different spot
#29 New York Jets - DE, Jerry Hughes 05 points, different position, 2 spots off
#30 Minnesota Vikings - DT, Brian Price 0 points, different position
#31 Indianapolis Colts - DT, Tyson Alualu 0 points, different position
#32 New Orleans Saints - DE, Corey Wooten 0 points, different position


--------------------
You still can get points for Brian Price and Corey Wooten, but your total for now would be: 89 points


I will make the scoring for everybody, creat a list and then post it here.

[BradyT]

Detailed scoring by every participant as follows - a list with the final results will be released
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Salty Dawg:

1. Rams (1-15) - Sam Bradford, QB, Oklahoma 11 pts
2. Lions (2-14) - Ndamukong Suh, DT, Nebraska - 11 pts
3. Buccaneers (3-13) - Gerald McCoy, DT, Oklahoma 11 pts
4. Redskins (4-12) - Russell Okung, LT, Oklahoma St. 9 pts
5. Chiefs (4-12) - Trent Williams, OT, Oklahoma 7 pts
6. Seahawks (5-11) - Bryan Bulaga, LT, Iowa 9 pts
7. Browns (5-11) - Eric Berry, S, Tennessee 5 pts
8. Raiders (5-11) - Derrick Morgan, DE, Georgia Tech
9. Bills (6-10) -Dan Williams, DT, Tennessee
10. Jaguars (7-9) - Earl Thomas, S, Texas 1 pt
11. Broncos (from Bears, 7-9) - Dez Bryant, WR, Oklahoma St.
12. Dolphins (7-9) - Rolando McClain, LB, Alabama 1 pt
13. 49ers (8-8) - Joe Haden, CB, Florida
14. Seahawks (from Broncos, 8-8) - Jimmy Clausen, QB, Notre Dame
15. Giants (8-8) - C.J. Spiller, RB, Clemson
16. Titans (8-8) - Everson Griffin, DE, USC 9 pts
17. 49ers (from Panthers, 8-8) - Mike Iupati, OL, Idaho 11 pts
18. Steelers (9-7) - Maurkice Pouncey, C/OG, Florida 11 pts
19. Falcons (9-7) - Jason Pierre-Paul, DE, South Florida 1 pt
20. Texans (9-7) - Kyle Wilson, CB, Boise St. 9 pt
21. Bengals (10-6) - Taylor Mays, S, USC
22. Patriots (10-6) - Brandon Graham, DE, Michigan
23. Packers (11-5) - Anthony Davis, LT, Rutgers 9 pts
24. Eagles (11-5) - Sean Weatherspoon, LB, Missouri
25. Ravens (9-7) - DeMaryius Thomas WR GT 3 pts
26. Cardinals (10-6) - Sergio Kindle, LB, Texas
27. Cowboys (11-5) - Bruce Campbell, LT, Maryland
28. Chargers (13-3) - Ryan Matthews, RB, Fresno St.
29. Jets (9-7) - Sergio Kindle LB TEx
30. Vikings (12-4) - Kareem Jackson CB ALA
31. Colts (14-2) - Brian Price, DT, UCLA
32. Saints (13-3) - Jerry Hughes, LB, TCU7 pts

=> 125 pts

Still open: Sergio Kindle and Brian Price

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

rkrazy:

1. Rams (1-15) - Sam Bradford, QB, Oklahoma 11 pts
2. Lions (2-14) - Ndamukong Suh, DT, Nebraska 11 pts
3. Buccaneers (3-13) - Gerald McCoy, DT, Oklahoma 11 pts
4. Redskins (4-12) - Russell Okung, LT, Oklahoma St. 9 pts
5. Chiefs (4-12) - Bryan Bulaga, LT, Iowa
6. Seahawks (5-11) - Trent Williams, OT, Oklahoma 5 pts
7. Browns (5-11) - Eric Berry, S, Tennessee 5 pts
8. Raiders (5-11) - Everson Griffin, DE, USC
9. Bills (6-10) - Jimmy Clausen, QB, Notre Dame
10. Jaguars (7-9) - Earl Thomas, S, Texas 1 pt
11. Broncos (from Bears, 7-9) - Dez Bryant, WR, Oklahoma St.
12. Dolphins (7-9) - Dan Williams, DT, Tennessee
13. 49ers (8-8) - Joe Haden, CB, Florida
14. Seahawks (from Broncos, 8-8) - Derrick Morgan, DE, Georgia Tech 5 pts
15. Giants (8-8) - Rolando McClain, LB, Alabama
16. Titans (8-8) - Jason Pierre-Paul, DE, South Florida 9 pts
17. 49ers (from Panthers, 8-8) - Mike Iupati, OL, Idaho 11 pts
18. Steelers (9-7) - Maurkice Pouncey, C/OG, Florida 11 pts
19. Falcons (9-7) - C.J. Spiller, RB, Clemson
20. Texans (9-7) - Kyle Wilson, CB, Boise St. 9 pts
21. Bengals (10-6) - Taylor Mays, S, USC
22. Patriots (10-6) - Jared Odrick, DL, Penn St.
23. Packers (11-5) - Anthony Davis, LT, Rutgers 9 pts
24. Eagles (11-5) - Brandon Graham, DE, Michigan
25. Ravens (9-7) - Sean Weatherspoon, LB, Missouri
26. Cardinals (10-6) - Sergio Kindle, LB, Texas
27. Cowboys (11-5) - Bruce Campbell, LT, Maryland
28. Chargers (13-3) - Ryan Matthews, RB, Fresno St.
29. Jets (9-7) - Jerry Hughes, LB, TCU 5 pts
30. Vikings (12-4) - Colt McCoy, QB, Texas
31. Colts (14-2) - Brian Price, DT, UCLA
32. Saints (13-3) - Carlos Dunlap, DE, Florida

=>112

Still open:Colt McCoy, Brian Price,Carlos Dunlap

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

bobbytheo3:

1 Rams - Sam Bradford, QB 11 pts
2 Lions - Ndamukong Suh, DT 11 pts
3 Bucs - Gerald McCoy, DT 11 pts
4 Redskins - Russel Okung 9 pts
5 Chiefs - Trent Williams 7 pts
6 Seahawks - Eric Berry 7 pts
7 Browns - Jimmy Clausen
8 Raiders - Bruce Campbell
9 Bills - Brian Bulaga
10 Jaguars - Tim Tebow
11 Broncos - Dez Bryant
12 Dolphins - Derrick Morgan 1 pt
13 49ers - Joe Haden
14 Seahawks - CJ Spiller
15 Giants - Rolando McCain
16 Titans - Jason Paul-Pierre 9 pts
17 49ers - Earl Thomas 3 pts
18 Steelers - Kyle Wilson
19 Falcons - Jahvid Best
20 Texans - Dan Williams
21 Bengals - Jermaine Greshem 11 pts
22 Patriots - Ryan Mathews
23 Packers - Kareem Jackson 3 pts
24 Eagles - Maurkice Pouncey
25 Ravens - Arrelius Benn
26 Cardinals - Sean Weatherspoon
27 Cowboys - Golden Tate
28 Chargers - Charles Brown
29 Jets - Terrence Cody
30 Vikings - Sergio Kindle
31 Colts - Mike Iupati
32 Saints - Brandon Graham

=>83 pts

Still open: Terrence Cody,Sergio Kindle

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

outrage(has sent me his mock with the correct draft order in time):

1 Rams - Sam Bradford, QB 11 pts
2 Lions - Ndamukong Suh, DT 11 pts
3 Bucs - Gerald McCoy, DT 11 pts
4 Redskins - Russell Okung, OT 9 pts
5 Chiefs - Eric Berry, S 11 pts
6 Seahawks - Trent Williams, OT 5 pts
7 Browns - Joe Haden, CB 11 pts
8 Raiders - Mike Iupati, OG
9 Bills - Bryan Bulaga, OT
10 Jaguars - Jason Pierre-Paul, DE
11 Broncos - Maurkice Pouncey, C/G
12 Dolphins - Dan Williams, DT
13 49ers - Derrick Morgan, DE 3 pts
14 Seahawks - C.J. Spiller, RB
15 Giants - Rolando McClain, ILB
16 Titans - Earl Thomas, S 5 pts
17 49ers - Anthony Davis, OT
18 Steelers - Kareem Jackson, CB 5 pts
19 Falcons - Dez Bryant, WR
20 Texans - Ryan Mathews, RB
21 Bengals - Jermaine Gresham, TE 11 pts
22 Patriots - Sergio Kindle, DE
23 Packers - Bruce Campbell, OT 9 pts
24 Eagles - Sean Weatherspoon, OLB
25 Ravens - Taylor Mays, S
26 Cardinals - Kyle Wilson, CB 3 pts
27 Cowboys - Charles Brown, OT
28 Chargers - Brian Price, OT
29 Jets - Brandon Graham, DE
30 Vikings - Jimmy Clausen, QB
31 Colts - Rodger Saffold, OT
32 Saints - Everson Griffen, DE

=>105

Still open: Jimmy Clausen,Rodger Saffold,Everson Griffen

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

GridIronFavre:

#1 St. Louis Rams – QB Sam Bradford (Oklahoma) 11 pts
#2 Detroit Lions – DT Ndamukong Suh (Nebraska) 11 pts
#3 Tampa Bay Buccaneers – DT Gerald McCoy (Oklahoma) 11 pts
#4 Washington Redskins – OT Trent Williams (Oklahoma) 11 pts
#5 Kansas City Chiefs – S Eric Berry (Tennessee) 11 pts
#6 Seattle Seahawks – OT Russell Okung (Oklahoma State) 11 pts
#7 Cleveland Browns – S Earl Thomas (Texas)
#8 Oakland Raiders – G Mike Iupati (Idaho)
#9 Buffalo Bills – OT Bryan Bulaga (Iowa)
#10 Jacksonville Jaguars – DE Derrick Morgan (Georgia Tech)
#11 Denver Broncos – WR Dez Bryant (Oklahoma State)
#12 Miami Dolphins – DT Dan Williams (Tennessee)
#13 San Francisco 49ers – CB Joe Haden (Florida)
#14 Seattle Seahawks – RB CJ Spiller (Clemson)
#15 New York Giants – LB Ronaldo McClain (Alabama)
#16 Tennessee Titans – DE Jason Pierre-Paul (South Florida) 9 pts
#17 San Francisco 49ers – OT Anthony Davis (Rutgers)
#18 Pittsburgh Steelers – C Maurkice Pouncey (Florida) 11 pts
#19 Atlanta Falcons – LB Brandon Graham (Michigan)
#20 Houston Texans – CB Kyle Wilson (Boise State) 9 pts
#21 Cincinnati Bengals – S Taylor Mays (USC)
#22 New England Patriots – LB Sergio Kindle (Texas)
#23 Green Bay Packers – LB Jerry Hughes (TCU)
#24 Philadelphia Eagles – CB Devin McCourty (Rutgers) 3 pts
#25 Baltimore Ravens – CB Kareem Jackson (Alabama)
#26 Arizona Cardinals – LB Sean Witherspoon (Missouri)
#27 Dallas Cowboys – OT Charles Brown (USC)
#28 San Diego Chargers – RB Ryan Matthews (Fresno State)
#29 New York Jets – DT Jared Odrick (Penn State) 7 pts
#30 Minnesota Vikings – QB Jimmy Clausen (Notre Dame)
#31 Indianapolis Colts – OT Roger Saffold (Indiana)
#32 New Orleans Saints – DT Bryan Price (UCLA)

=> 105 pts

Still open: Jimmy Clausen,Roger Saffold,Brian Price

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

hosler427:

#1 St. Louis Rams - Sam Bradford QB Oklahoma 11 pts
#2 Detroit Lions - Ndamukong Suh DT Nebraska 11 pts
#3 Tampa Bay Buccaneers - Gerald McCoy DT Oklahoma 11 pts
#4 Washington Redskins - Russell Okung OT Oklahoma State 9 pts
#5 Kansas City Chiefs - Eric Berry S Tennessee 11 pts
#6 Seattle Seahawks - CJ Spiller RB Clemson 3 pts
#7 Cleveland Browns - Joe Haden CB Florida 11 pts
#8 Oakland Raiders - Trent Williams OT Oklahoma 1 pt
#9 Buffalo Bills - Bryan Bulaga OT Iowa
#10 Jacksonville Jaguars - Rolando McClain ILB Alabama 5 pts
#11 Denver Broncos - Dan Williams DT Tennessee
#12 Miami Dolphins - Earl Thomas S Texas 5 pts
#13 San Francisco 49ers - Anthony Davis OT Rutgers 5 pts
#14 Seattle Seahawks - Derrick Morgan DE Georgia Tech 5 pts
#15 New York Giants - Jason Pierre-Paul DE South Florida 11 pts
#16 Tennessee Titans - Brandon Graham DE Michigan 9 pts
#17 San Francisco 49ers - Jimmy Clausen QB Notre Dame
#18 Pittsburgh Steelers - Dez Bryant WR Oklahoma State
#19 Atlanta Falcons - Demaryious Thomas WR Georgia Tech 3 pts
#20 Houston Texans - Kyle Wilson CB Boise State 9 pts
#21 Cincinnati Bengals - Mike Iupati OG Idaho 1 pt
#22 New England Patriots - Jared Odrick DE Penn State
#23 Green Bay Packers - Bruce Campbell OT Maryland 9 pts
#24 Philadelphia Eagles - Maurkice Pouncey OC Florida
#25 Baltimore Ravens - Sean Weatherspoon LB Missouri
#26 Arizona Cardinals - Sergio Kindle OLB Texas
#27 Dallas Cowboys - Nate Allen S South Florida
#28 San Diego Chargers - Terrence Cody NT Alabama
#29 New York Jets - Jerry Hughes OLB TCU 5 pts
#30 Minnesota Vikings - Kareem Jackson CB Alabama
#31 Indianapolis Colts - Charles Brown OT USC
#32 New Orleans Saints - Everson Griffen DE USC

=>135 pts

Still open: Charles Brown, Everson Griffen

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Misfit74:

1. St. Louis Rams …. Sam Bradford QB 11 pts
2. Detroit Lions …. Ndamukong Suh DT 11 pts
3. Tampa Bay Buccaneers …. Gerald McCoy DT 11 pts
4. Washington Redskins …. Trent Williams OT 11 pts
5. Kansas City Chiefs …. Russell Okung OT 7 pts
6. Seattle Seahawks …. Eric Berry S 7 pts
7. Cleveland Browns …. Kyle Wilson CB 9 pts
8. Oakland Raiders …. Anthony Davis OT 3 pts
9. Buffalo Bills …. Brian Bulaga OT
10. Jacksonville Jaguars …. Derrick Morgan DE
11. Denver Broncos …. Dez Bryant WR
12. Miami Dolphins …. Dan Williams NT
13. San Francisco 49ers …. Joe Haden CB
14. Seattle Seahawks …. C.J. Spiller RB
15. New York Giants …. Rolando McClain ILB
16. Tennessee Titans …. Jason Pierre-Paul DE 9 pts
17. San Francisco 49ers …. Charles Brown OT
18. Pittsburgh Steelers …. Mike Iupati OG 7 pts
19. Atlanta Falcons …. Brandon Graham DE
20. Houston Texans …. Ryan Mathews RB
21. Cincinnati Bengals …. Jimmy Clausen QB
22. New England Patriots …. Jared Odrick DT/DE
23. Green Bay Packers …. Devin McCourty CB 1 pt
24. Philadelphia Eagles …. Earl Thomas S
25. Baltimore Ravens …. Terrence Cody NT
26. Arizona Cardinals …. Sean Weatherspoon OLB
27. Dallas Cowboys …. Bruce Campbell OT
28. San Diego Chargers …. Linval Joseph DT/DE
29. New York Jets …. Carlos Dunlap DE
30. Minnesota Vikings …. Brian Price DT
31. Indianapolis Colts …. Maurkice Pouncey C/OG
32. New Orleans Saints …. Jerry Hughes OLB 7 pts

=>94 pts

Still open: Carlos Dunlap,Brian Price

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

BubbaBurst:

#1 St. Louis Rams - Sam Bradford, QB, Oklahoma 11 pts
#2 Detroit Lions - Ndamukong Suh, DT, Nebraska 11 pts
#3 Tampa Bay Buccaneers - Gerald McCoy, DT, Oklahoma 11 pts
#4 Washington Redskins - Trent Williams, OT, Oklahoma 11 pts
#5 Kansas City Chiefs - Russell Okung, OT, Oklahoma State 7 pts
#6 Seattle Seahawks - Eric Berry, S, Tennessee 7 pts
#7 Cleveland Browns - Dez Bryant, WR, Oklahoma State
#8 Oakland Raiders - Mike Iupati, G, Idaho
#9 Buffalo Bills - Dan Williams, DT, Tennessee
#10 Jacksonville Jaguars - Derrick Morgan, DE, Georgia Tech
#11 Denver Broncos - Earl Thomas, S, Texas 3 pts
#12 Miami Dolphins - Sergio Kindle, Texas, OLB
#13 San Francisco 49ers - Brian Bulaga, OT, Iowa
#14 Seattle Seahawks - CJ Spiller, RB, Clemson
#15 New York Giants - Brandon Graham, DE, Michigan 9 pts
#16 Tennessee Titans - Jason Pierre-Paul, DE, South Florida 9 pts
#17 San Francisco 49ers - Joe Haden, CB, Florida
#18 Pittsburgh Steelers - Rolando McClain, LB, Alabama
#19 Atlanta Falcons - Sean Weatherspoon, OLB, Missouri 11 pts
#20 Houston Texans - Kyle Wilson, CB, Boise State 9 pts
#21 Cincinnati Bengals - Jimmy Clausen, QB, Notre Dame
#22 New England Patriots - Brian Price, DT, UCLA
#23 Green Bay Packers - Charles Brown, OT, USC 9 pts
#24 Philadelphia Eagles - Taylor Mays, S, USC
#25 Baltimore Ravens - Jared Odrick, DT, Penn State 3 pts
#26 Arizona Cardinals - Jerry Hughes, OLB, TCU
#27 Dallas Cowboys - Anthony Davis, OT, Rutgers
#28 San Diego Chargers - Kareem Jackson, CB, Alabama
#29 New York Jets - Roger Saffold, OT, Indiana
#30 Minnesota Vikings - Devin McCourty, CB, Rutgers 3 pts
#31 Indianapolis Colts - Carlos Dunlap, DE, Florida
#32 New Orleans Saints - Everson Griffen, DE, USC

=>114 pts

Still open: Roger Saffold,Carlos Dunlap,Everson Griffen

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Vintage:

#1 St. Louis Rams - QB, Sam Bradford 11 pts
#2 Detroit Lions - DT, Ndamukong Suh 11 pts
#3 Tampa Bay Buccaneers - DT, Gerald McCoy 11 pts
#4 Washington Redskins - OT, Russell Okung 9 pts
#5 Kansas City Chiefs - OT, Trent Williams 7 pts
#6 Seattle Seahawks - OT, Bryan Bulaga 9 pts
#7 Cleveland Browns - CB, Eric Berry 5 pts
#8 Oakland Raiders - DE, Jason Pierre-Paul
#9 Buffalo Bills - QB, Jimmy Clausen
#10 Jacksonville Jaguars - DE, Derrick Morgan
#11 Denver Broncos - WR, Dez Bryant
#12 Miami Dolphins - LB, Rolando McClain 1 pt
#13 San Francisco 49ers - CB, Joe Haden
#14 Seattle Seahawks - DE Everson Griffen
#15 New York Giants - DT, Dan Williams
#16 Tennessee Titans - DE, Brandon Graham 9 pts
#17 San Francisco 49ers - OT, Bruce Campbell
#18 Pittsburgh Steelers - RB, CJ Spiller
#19 Atlanta Falcons - LB, Sergio Kindle
#20 Houston Texans - S, Earl Thomas
#21 Cincinnati Bengals - OG, Mike Iupati 1 pt
#22 New England Patriots - DT, Jared Odrick
#23 Green Bay Packers - OT, Anthony Davis 9 pts
#24 Philadelphia Eagles - DE, Carlos Dunlap
#25 Baltimore Ravens - CB, Kyle Wilson 1 pt
#26 Arizona Cardinals - LB, Sean Weatherspoon
#27 Dallas Cowboys - S, Taylor Mays
#28 San Diego Chargers - RB, Ryan Mathews
#29 New York Jets - DE, Jerry Hughes 5 pts
#30 Minnesota Vikings - DT, Brian Price
#31 Indianapolis Colts - DT, Tyson Alualu
#32 New Orleans Saints - DE, Corey Wooten

=>89 pts

still open: Brian Price,Corey Wooten

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

hot nikkels:

#1 St. Louis Rams - QB, Sam Bradford 11 pts
#2 Detroit Lions - DT, Ndamukong Suh 11 pts
#3 Tampa Bay Buccaneers - DT, Gerald McCoy 11 pts
#4 Washington Redskins - OT, Russell Okung 9 pts
#5 Kansas City Chiefs - OT, Bryan Bulaga
#6 Seattle Seahawks - OT, Trent Williams 9 pts
#7 Cleveland Browns - S, Eric Berry 5 pts
#8 Oakland Raiders - OT, Anthony Davis 3 pts
#9 Buffalo Bills - DT, Dan Williams
#10 Jacksonville Jaguars - S, Earl Thomas 1 pt
#11 Denver Broncos - ILB, Rolando McClain 3 pts
#12 Miami Dolphins - OLB, Sergio Kindle
#13 San Francisco 49ers - CB, Joe Haden
#14 Seattle Seahawks - WR, Dez Bryant
#15 New York Giants - CB, Kyle Wilson
#16 Tennessee Titans - DT, Brian Price
#17 San Francisco 49ers - OG, Mike Iupati 11 pts
#18 Pittsburgh Steelers - OLB, Brandon Graham
#19 Atlanta Falcons - DE, Derrick Morgan
#20 Houston Texans - S, Taylor Mays
#21 Cincinnati Bengals - TE, Jermaine Gresham 11 pts
#22 New England Patriots - DE, Jared Odrick
#23 Green Bay Packers - OT, Charles Brown 9 pts
#24 Philadelphia Eagles - OLB, Sean Witherspoon
#25 Baltimore Ravens - DE, Carlos Dunlap
#26 Arizona Cardinals - ILB, Brandon Spikes
#27 Dallas Cowboys - OT, Bruce Campbell
#28 San Diego Chargers - RB, Ryan Mathews
#29 New York Jets - DE, Jason Pierre-Paul
#30 Minnesota Vikings - DT, Terrance Cody
#31 Indianapolis Colts - C/G, Maurkice Pouncey
#32 New Orleans Saints - DE Everson Griffen

=>94 pts

Still open:Terrence Cody,Everson Griffen

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

skip:

#1 St. Louis Rams - Sam Bradford, QB 11 pts
#2 Detroit Lions - Ndamukong Suh, DT 11 pts
#3 Tampa Bay Buccaneers - Gerald McCoy, DT 11 pts
#4 Washington Redskins - Russell Okung, OT 9 pts
#5 Kansas City Chiefs - Bryan Bulaga, OT
#6 Seattle Seahawks - Trent Williams, OT 9 pts
#7 Cleveland Browns - Eric Berry, S 5 pts
#8 Oakland Raiders - Bruce Campbell, OT
#9 Buffalo Bills - Jimmy Claussen, QB
#10 Jacksonville Jaguars - Jason Pierre-Paul, DE
#11 Denver Broncos - Dez Bryant, WR
#12 Miami Dolphins - Dan Williams, DT
#13 San Francisco 49ers - Derrick Morgan, DE 3 pts
#14 Seattle Seahawks - CJ Spiller, RB
#15 New York Giants - Rolando McClain, LB
#16 Tennessee Titans - Brandon Graham, DE 9 pts
#17 San Francisco 49ers - Joe Haden, CB
#18 Pittsburgh Steelers - Mike Iupati, OG 7 pts
#19 Atlanta Falcons - Kyle Wilson, CB
#20 Houston Texans - Ryan Matthews, RB
#21 Cincinnati Bengals - Jermaine Gresham, TE 11 pts
#22 New England Patriots - Sergio Kindle, LB
#23 Green Bay Packers - Charles Brown, OT 9 pts
#24 Philadelphia Eagles - Sean Weatherspoon, LB
#25 Baltimore Ravens - Jared Odrick, DE 3 pts
#26 Arizona Cardinals - Anthony Davis, OT
#27 Dallas Cowboys - Earl Thomas, S
#28 San Diego Chargers - Jonathan Dwyer, RB
#29 New York Jets - Carlos Dunlap, DE
#30 Minnesota Vikings - Maurkice Pouncey, C/G
#31 Indianapolis Colts - Terrence Cody, DT
#32 New Orleans Saints - Jerry Hughes, LB 7 pts

=>105

Still open: Carlos Dunlap,Terrence Cody

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

grimace:

#1 St. Louis Rams - Sam Bradford, QB, Oklahoma 11 pts
#2 Detroit Lions - Gerald McCoy DT, Oklahoma 9 pts
#3 Tampa Bay Buccaneers - Ndomukong Su DT Nebraska 9 pts
#4 Washington Redskins - Russle Okung OT Oklahoma State 9 pts
#5 Kansas City Chiefs - Bryan Bulaga OT Iowa
#6 Seattle Seahawks - Trent Williams OT Oklahoma 9 pts
#7 Cleveland Browns - Joe Haden CB Florida 11 pts
#8 Oakland Raiders - Eric Berry S Tennessee 3 pts
#9 Buffalo Bills - Jimmy Clausen QB Notre Dame
#10 Jacksonville Jaguars - Jason Pierre-Paul DE South Florida
#11 Denver Broncos - Rolando McClain LB Alabama 3 pts
#12 Miami Dolphins - Dan Williams DT Tennessee
#13 San Francisco 49ers - Anthony Davis OT Rutgers 5 pts
#14 Seattle Seahawks - Dez Bryant WR Oklahoma State
#15 New York Giants - Derrick Morgan DE GTech 9 pts
#16 Tennessee Titans - Carlos Dunlap DE Florida 9 pts
#17 San Francisco 49ers - CJ Spiller RB Clemson
#18 Pittsburgh Steelers - Demaryius Thoams WR GTech 1 pt
#19 Atlanta Falcons - Kyle Wilson CB Boise State
#20 Houston Texans - Mike Iupati OG Idaho 3 pts
#21 Cincinnati Bengals - Earl Thomas S Texas
#22 New England Patriots - Ryan Mathews RB Fresno State
#23 Green Bay Packers - Brandon Graham OLB Michigan
#24 Philadelphia Eagles - Sean Witherspoon OLB Missouri
#25 Baltimore Ravens - Jeremaine Gresham TE Oklahoma 1 pt
#26 Arizona Cardinals - Sergio Kindle OLB Texas
#27 Dallas Cowboys - Taylor Mays S USC
#28 San Diego Chargers - Brian Price DT UCLA
#29 New York Jets - Jared Odrick DT Penn State 7 pts
#30 Minnesota Vikings - Tim Tebow QB Florida
#31 Indianapolis Colts - Maurkice Pouncey G/C Florida
#32 New Orleans Saints - Devin McCourty CB Rutgers 9 pts

=>108 pts

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Phis Brigade:

#1 St. Louis Rams - Sam Bradford, QB, Oklahoma 11 pts
#2 Detroit Lions - Ndamukong Suh, DT, Nebraska 11 pts
#3 Tampa Bay Buccaneers - Gerald McCoy, DT, Oklahoma 11 pts
#4 Washington Redskins - Russell Okung, OT, Oklahoma State 9 pts
#5 Kansas City Chiefs - Trent Williams, OT, Oklahoma 7 pts
#6 Seattle Seahawks - Anthony Davis, OT, Rutgers 9 pts
#7 Cleveland Browns - Eric Berry, S, Tennessee 5 pts
#8 Oakland Raiders - Jason Pierre-Paul, DE, South Florida
#9 Buffalo Bills - Brian Bulaga, OT, Iowa
#10 Jacksonville Jaguars - Derrick Morgan, DE, Georgia Tech
#11 Denver Broncos - Earl Thomas, S, Texas 3 pts
#12 Miami Dolphins - Dan Williams, DT, Tennessee
#13 San Francisco 49ers - Joe Haden, CB, Florida
#14 Seattle Seahawks - CJ Spiller, RB, Clemson
#15 New York Giants - Rolando McClain, LB, Alabama
#16 Tennessee Titans - Brandon Graham, DE, Michigan 9 pts
#17 San Francisco 49ers - Charles Brown, OT, USC
#18 Pittsburgh Steelers - Mike Iupati, G, Idaho 7 pts
#19 Atlanta Falcons - Sean Weatherspoon, OLB, Missouri 11 pts
#20 Houston Texans - Kyle WIlson, CB, Boise State 9 pts
#21 Cincinnati Bengals - Jermaine Gresham, TE, Oklahoma 11 pts
#22 New England Patriots - Jared Odrick, DE, Penn State
#23 Green Bay Packers - Sergio Kindle, OLB, Texas
#24 Philadelphia Eagles - Jerry Hughes, DE/OLB, TCU
#25 Baltimore Ravens - Kareem Jackson, CB, Alabama
#26 Arizona Cardinals - Jimmy Clausen, QB, Notre Dame
#27 Dallas Cowboys - Dez Bryant, WR, Oklahoma State 3 pts
#28 San Diego Chargers - Ryan Mathews, RB, Fresno State
#29 New York Jets - Maurkice Pouncey, C, Florida
#30 Minnesota Vikings - Devin McCourty, CB, Rutgers 3 pts
#31 Indianapolis Colts - Roger Saffold, OT, Indiana
#32 New Orleans Saints - Brian Price, DT, UCLA

=>119 pts

Still open: Roger Saffold,Brian Price

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

BradyT:

#1 St. Louis Rams - Sam Bradford,QB,Oklahoma 11 pts
#2 Detroit Lions - Ndamukong Suh,DT, Nebraska 11 pts
#3 Tampa Bay Buccaneers - Gerald McCoy,DT,Oklahoma 11 pts
#4 Washington Redskins - Russell Okung,OT, Oklahoma State 9 pts
#5 Kansas City Chiefs - Brian Bulaga,OT,Iowa
#6 Seattle Seahawks - Trent Williams,OT,Oklahoma 9 pts
#7 Cleveland Browns - Eric Berry,S,Tennessee 5 pts
#8 Oakland Raiders - Bruce Campbell,OT,Maryland
#9 Buffalo Bills - Jimmy Claussen,QB,Notre Dame
#10 Jacksonville Jaguars - Jason Pierre-Paul,DE,South Florida
#11 Denver Broncos - Dez Bryant,WR,Oklahoma State
#12 Miami Dolphins - Dan Williams,DT,Tennessee
#13 San Francisco 49ers - Anthony Davis,OT,Rutgers 5 pts
#14 Seattle Seahawks - C.J.Spiller,RB,Clemson
#15 New York Giants - Rolando McClain,LB,Alabama
#16 Tennessee Titans - Joe Haden,CB,Florida
#17 San Francisco 49ers - Taylor Mays,S,USC
#18 Pittsburgh Steelers - Kyle Wilson,CB,Boise State
#19 Atlanta Falcons - Derrick Morgan,DE,Georgia Tech 3 pts
#20 Houston Texans - Earl Thomas,S,Texas
#21 Cincinnati Bengals - Jermaine Gresham,TE,Oklahoma 11 pts
#22 New England Patriots - Sergio Kindle,DE,Texas
#23 Green Bay Packers - Patrick Robinson,CB,Florida State
#24 Philadelphia Eagles - Sean Weatherspoon,LB,Missouri
#25 Baltimore Ravens - Jared Odrick,DT,Penn State 3 pts
#26 Arizona Cardinals - Mike Iupati,OG,Idaho
#27 Dallas Cowboys - Charles Brown,OT,USC
#28 San Diego Chargers - Terrence Cody,DT,Alabama
#29 New York Jets - Jerry Hughes,LB,TCU 5 pts
#30 Minnesota Vikings - Maurkice Pouncey,C,Florida
#31 Indianapolis Colts - Tim Tebow,QB,Florida
#32 New Orleans Saints - Brandon Graham,DE,Michigan

=>83

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
If you think there i an mistake in your scoring, please write to me.

[skip]

#19 Atlanta Falcons - LB, Sergio Kindle 09 points, different player, same position 0 points.. while Kindle might play LB, he´s a DE coming into this draft

Have to disagree with you here, Brady. There was no defined location as far as "going into the draft". There are players listed as DTs and/or DEs depending on the site you use. On the sites I use, Kindle was listed as an LB. Clearly I am not the only one as almost every mock in this thread has him listed the same way.

[hosler427]

#19 Atlanta Falcons - LB, Sergio Kindle 09 points, different player, same position 0 points.. while Kindle might play LB, he´s a DE coming into this draft

Have to disagree with you here, Brady. There was no defined location as far as "going into the draft". There are players listed as DTs and/or DEs depending on the site you use. On the sites I use, Kindle was listed as an LB. Clearly I am not the only one as almost every mock in this thread has him listed the same way.

Have to agree with skip....Many experts believed that Kindle could play LB in a 4-3 or a 3-4. He isn't a typical conversion guy...

[Phish Brigade]

Have to agree on the Kindle debate, I'd say he's a OLB. It's the 3-4 teams that were rumored to have him on their draft boards for the most part.

Thanks for the update Brady! And well done Dan.

Just curious though, wouldn't anyone who selected Derrick Morgan ( or any DE ) at #10 get 9 points since the Jags drafted a DE?

[hosler427]

Have to agree on the Kindle debate, I'd say he's a OLB. It's the 3-4 teams that were rumored to have him on their draft boards for the most part.

Thanks for the update Brady! And well done Dan.

Just curious though, wouldn't anyone who selected Derrick Morgan ( or any DE ) at #10 get 9 points since the Jags drafted a DE?

I say no...Tyson Alualu is a clear cut DT in the Jags system so I don't think a DE could get the points. I think we should come up with a system that is more clear next year though...just my 2 cents The first year doing anything is a learning experience though. Thanks Brady!!

[skip]

Just curious though, wouldn't anyone who selected Derrick Morgan ( or any DE ) at #10 get 9 points since the Jags drafted a DE?

Cut Brady some slack on that one. Probably caught him off guard since the general reaction was probably "Who is Tyson Alualu?"

[hosler427]

Just curious though, wouldn't anyone who selected Derrick Morgan ( or any DE ) at #10 get 9 points since the Jags drafted a DE?

Cut Brady some slack on that one. Probably caught him off guard since the general reaction was probably "Who is Tyson Alualu?"

I love Alualu and I was hoping he would be around at the beginning of the 2nd round so the Giants could trade up for him. I thought he was worthy of a first round pick...just not top 10 though. That surprised me almost as much as Al Davis making a good pick for the Raiders.

[Phish Brigade]

Have to agree on the Kindle debate, I'd say he's a OLB. It's the 3-4 teams that were rumored to have him on their draft boards for the most part.

Thanks for the update Brady! And well done Dan.

Just curious though, wouldn't anyone who selected Derrick Morgan ( or any DE ) at #10 get 9 points since the Jags drafted a DE?

I say no...Tyson Alualu is a clear cut DT in the Jags system so I don't think a DE could get the points. I think we should come up with a system that is more clear next year though...just my 2 cents The first year doing anything is a learning experience though. Thanks Brady!!

True. Good point Dan.

Mad love to the Bradymeister for doing the math!

[thewhyterabbit]

Just curious though, wouldn't anyone who selected Derrick Morgan ( or any DE ) at #10 get 9 points since the Jags drafted a DE?

Cut Brady some slack on that one. Probably caught him off guard since the general reaction was probably "Who is Tyson Alualu?"

I love Alualu and I was hoping he would be around at the beginning of the 2nd round so the Giants could trade up for him. I thought he was worthy of a first round pick...just not top 10 though. That surprised me almost as much as Al Davis making a good pick for the Raiders.

terrible pick at 1.9..... god awful... did i like him at the senior bowl?!?! HECK yea... but top 10? phshhhhhhh

[Scorp]

#7 Cleveland Browns - CB, Eric Berry 09 points different player, correct position 5 points - Eric Berry is a Safety, not CB, allthough he might play CB from time to time.. but that doesn´t count here

The reason I marked Berry as a corner is because I felt they would draft him as a corner, and I'm not going to argue about the points, but thought it counted if they drafted him to replace a corner instead of a safety. This was done intentionally because I thought Cleveland would also consider CB Joe Haden, which they did, but I thought you had to pick the position example like Pierre-Paul could end up being a LB or DE.

[rkrazy]

Question about the scoring. I had Mathews to SD @ 28 and Graham to Iggles @ 24 but received 0 points for both. Both players were drafted by the team I had for them only in different spots because of trades. Shouldn't those selections be worth something too?

[BradyT]

Kindle debate: I took the fact him beinga DE at Texas - and there was something written in the first post:

Some side notes: (important for the 9 point rule)

....

3) We do make a difference between OLB and DE(allthough he now plays OLB, Brian Orakpo was drafted as a DE, which would mean him counting as a DE)

And I bet he will be announced as a DE when he´s drafted later this evening. Lets wait on his actualy selection and what position is announced.

Allthough I think we should take the position a player has played (most of the time) in college, let the actuall selection decide this Kindle case.

Next year it definately should be the college position that counts and not the possible/likely position in the NFL.


Tyson Alualu: clear cut DT imo - and that was also the position he played at college, the position he was coming with into the draft.



Eric Berry: he probably could play every position in the defense and probably will play CB from time to time.. but hands down: he is a safety, not CB.


@rkrazy: next year we can include something like that, but since we did not put this up before the draft, we should not change it now that the draft is over(atleast the 1st rd)

[skip]

Some of us don't follow college ball because we simply don't care. I went by where Kindle was listed on nearly every draft site out there. In the end, its about bragging rights and it doesn't matter anyway. I am not about to pore through college statistics to try to determine where a player played or not as its a bigger waste of time than watching college games themselves.