Dynasty League Football Forum

If you're rebuilding, I'm cashing out. To everyone who's saying just trade Kyren in-season for more, we're ignoring the possibility that (a) he's not as productive as last year, and/or (b) he gets injured. If it's, say, Breece Hall or Bijan, then I'm holding out. Even an injury wouldn't completely t...

I guess I'll be that guy... EASILY the future pick for me. There might be 14ish players (give or take) with a first-round grade, but there are about 8 players in the Tier 1 group. I'm happily trading a pick outside that group for one likely to be worth much, much more next year. Yes, there's risk. T...

Definite pass for me. 1) You don't know if R White is starting for you. You have 6 RBs each with different yet reasonable paths to meaningful playing time. Some are already the alpha on their team, and others have a path to get there. White would be another in the mix (closer to the alpha group, of ...

Anteaters wrote: ↑Fri May 03, 2024 6:22 am I agree it's a pain in the a** to trade with people.
That's why I conduct all my trades with myself or my dog. I never trade with people. And I always win my trades!

Calling you out here, dude. No way you win your trades with your dog!!

In a rebuild, the answer is whichever likely has more trade value.

That's Sutton, IMO -- and I'd take just about anything (even a 3rd) that I could get for him.

I'm going to throw something else out there: are you open to a longer rebuild? I like the idea of two firsts this year and one next year for Lamar, and I'm also with UsualSuspects that it's not quite enough (especially with neither 1st being early). I asked at the beginning, though, because 2025 and...

I get the Caleb hype. I really do. And I'm a Love truther. I really am. From week 10 on, Love was anywhere from QB2-QB5 depening on scoring systems, etc. Even if we all agree that Caleb has a higher ceiling, how much higher is the ceiling than what Love showed the back half of 2023? I know the argum...

Thank you!!!

I'll give one reason: some people might not follow college players too deeply and might really start researching rookies after the draft. For them, their baseline is draft capitol, landing spots, etc. rather than a purposefully-determined pre-draft ranking.

Is this really a start 1 WR league??

I would do it for 2.02. In a 10-team SF league, I'm almost 100% I'd rather have whatever RB is available then than Swift. I might be low on Swift, but it just doesn't seem like he's ever going to have a monster season. Good, solid, yes. But that doesn't really excite me. I'd rather the picks here ve...

Rice >> Stevenson
2.07 >>> 4.12
K Mitchell >>>

Massive win for you, IMO.

Definitely not too much to move up.

It also depends on the scoring system for Defenses. If they get a real bump, then it makes sense to me. It's hard to see Mayer ever becoming a player who's going to be a top-tier TE. Which means is realistic ceiling is second tier, and that's often close to replacement-level in leagues with standard...

Short term JJM. Long term Maye I get the thought that JJM will be more productive than Maye in the short-term. But will he really be *so* productive that you're using him on a championship team?? I highly doubt that will be the case, so I'm not factoring in production in this case over the next cou...